Jane Jacobs (1916-2006), who is an American-born Canadian journalist, author, social and urban activist, has been published the first of her many books; The Death and Life of Great American Cities in 1961. Jacobs is well-known with her observations on urban life and its problems. The book is consisted of four parts aim to introduce new principles different than the aims shaped modern city planning and rebuilding. Particularly the Part Two: The Conditions for City Diversity, where urbanity, diversity and vitality are discussed thoroughly, will be reviewed in this paper. The life and death of cities is proportional to the question of whether a city is livable or not, because the goal of urban design to create better place to people to live. The chapter is about the places of quality, while the book is a particularly important critic of modernist city as Jane Jacobs was completely against the operations of urban renewal. Indeed, it is a very influential book in urban design and planning. Throughout the book, Jacobs includes her observations, inferences and conclusions on real life of cities, on how cities ought to work and what ought to be good for people and businesses in them. Jacobs harshly criticizes modernist city approach, and certain practices of city planning. At those times, Jane Jacobs did not just passively express her thoughts, but she is also, actively, participated in protests, in which some urban renewal attempts in American cities are objected. It seems to me, her being an activist made her free in her thoughts, therefore she could express her inferences openly.
In general, the book is easily graspable by anyone interested in the ways in which cities operate since Jacobs writes about the things are familiar and held in common. If we can look at the cities we live in with critical eye, if we investigate why the shop under the opposite apartment changes hands many times in a short time, or the dwellings on a street have been vacant for months, how few people passing through the street except residents, how could the 30-storey construction with eight blocks on the side plot find a place there, at some point, we can make sense of this book within ourselves, at least that is what I did. I was able to find examples of many of the issues mentioned in the book from my own circle. Therefore, without hesitation, it can be said that the book, as being a sociological work, appeals to anyone, who observes, can connect with or relate to the general city and street atmosphere in which they live.
While the book generally concentrates on great cities, the problems in planning theory, Part Two and Jacobs (1961) specifically touches on how cities operate, “how cities work in real life and what practices in rebuilding can promote social and economic vitality in cities.” Cities are living organisms that live, transform, change shape over time. Far beyond whether the city that was planned years ago functions well, a plan may not have any of its features designed on a paper. In real life, with the involvement of the user, changing economic conditions, natural environment so on and so forth, city may be operating in a completely different way or it may not be working either anymore. However, the conditions necessary for the functioning of cities do not change but can vary. People come to cities to make use of the advantages of cities, of the diversified opportunities and activities is offers. People come to cities to be able to go theaters, events, exhibitions, concerts and so on. Therefore, cities need a most intricate diversity of uses that give each other continuous support, both economically and socially. “To understand cities, we have to deal outright with combinations or mixtures of uses, not separate uses, as the essential phenomena,” as Jacobs (1961) put forwards, because enough diversity is achieved through the enough mixture among uses. Most of the uses of diversity depend directly or indirectly upon the presence of plentiful and convenient diverse city commerce. This immense number and ranges of small enterprises generated by cities rest on the fact that people need so many different tastes, skills, supplies. To meet the diverse needs of people, cities must offer a certain mixture of activities. Accordingly, “cities have the capability of providing something for everybody, only because, and only when, they are created by everybody,” as Jacobs states. Therefore, the range encompasses grocery stores, pottery schools, movie theatres, candy stores, florists, art shows, galleries, immigrant’s clubs, hardware stores, eating places, and so on mutually support people, each other and city life.
Jacobs proposes that there are four primary conditions required for generating good urban spaces, good diversity in a city’sstreets and districts. These are the needs for primary mixed uses, the need for small blocks, the need for aged buildings, and the need for concentration. By consciously activating these four conditions and blending them together, a city district activates its best potential, vitality.
First, the need for primary mixed uses. As the first condition of diversity Jacobs (1961) argues that: The district, and indeed as many of its internal parts as possible, must serve more than one primary function: preferably more than two. These must insure the presence of people who go outdoors on different schedules and are in the place for different purposes, but who are able to use many facilities in common. (p. 152)
Offices, factories, dwellings, entertainment and education places, many museums, libraries introduce primary uses which is brought people to that specific place. However, to diversify and revive cities, it is needed a secondary use to combined with primary use that puts people on the street at different times. Here, Jane Jacobs (1961) mentions that “on successful city streets, people must appear at different times,”and adds that the significance of time spread can be seen clearly at the district embracing Wall Street in Manhattan, which is a district suffering from extreme time unbalance among its users. This situation is observable during the day. At weekday noon, a dense crowd of people going out for lunch taking up huge areas, while after five p.m. and weekends there is full silence. However, the district ought to offer other uses than business and spread people through time of day and serve mixed primary uses. Then, as attempts to revitalize the city with second uses, part of the district’s waterfront can be transformed into a marine museum or to build a new aquarium to the waterfront, as Jacobs proposes. This would liven up the district during weekends. Additionally, to revive a city, I think design of public spaces play a crucial role, because they provide communication, enjoyment and relaxation unlike routines of work and home. With street performances, protests, festivals, open markets and other interesting activity, public spaces can attract people and tourists who may then become good customers for retail business. This may be related to the tempo of the city; various uses increase the tempo. On the other hand, the pace of some cities is so low that I feel like I am not going to survive. How could the city not die?
Second, the need for small blocks. Here, Jacobs looks closely at how streets are working in vibrant urban district, then she (1961) asserts the second condition for city diversity which is “most blocks must be short; that is, streets and opportunities to turn corners must be frequent”.Long street blocks restrict the opportunities that would be offered by the street corner. They would cause separated and isolated long paths until reach a place where pool of use is formed, where people come together in one stream. I see that going the same way to a main axis, where all uses are gathered, brings monotony and dullness to the city and life, so cities still need alternative routes that offer various uses for the vitality to sustain. Having an extra street cutting across the long blocks allows creation of frequent streets and short blocks mixing with one another and then siting parks, squares, and public buildings at key locations. She concluded that a mixture of uses must be supported by frequent streets. Rockefeller Center in New York City, which provides new uses by adding streets cutting long blocks, is a particularly good example as Jacobs evokes in the book. It seems to me; Rockefeller center is also the prototype to produce diversity through the public space.
Third, the need for aged buildings. Jacobs (1961) suggest that “the district must mingle buildings that vary in age and condition, including a good proportion of old ones.” If we were talking about Roman city example, the aged buildings would gain importance in a quite different context, but in the case of America, Jacobs’ arguments for preserving old buildings are primarily economic and social rather than aesthetic or historical. Great cities are needed mix of buildings varying in age and condition. If a district consists only of new buildings, then only uses that can afford these economically can exist there whereas Jacobs mentions many times that diversity means the existence of various small uses, small enterprises. Thus, old buildings are crucial for enterprises that have a share in generating diversity but cannot afford high prices. Old buildings also offer low-cost housing. Besides economic concerns there is another dimension; heterogeneity, which buildings varying age and condition bring into open. Such heterogeneity might have ability to attract people to a specific district, I think. Another thing Jane Jacobs inference is that wiping out old buildings and constructing great swatches at one time is inevitably inefficient since populations and business prefer districts in which diversity is created through a good mix of buildings. In a vital city district that meets people needs, the brilliant adaptations and minor changes, where stable becomes house, or the garage becomes a theater, or the butcher shop becomes a restaurant occurs forever which is nice. Jacobs exemplifies that no building is underrated in New York City’s Greenwich Village as it is a successful district, on the other hand, in Miami Beach hotels ten years old are considered aged, and I think they are having aesthetic concerns, and are lost because others are newer and the new is the ruler there.
Fourth, the need for concentration. Jacobs observes a sufficiently dense concentration of people is necessary to enhance city diversity and asserts (1961) that “the district must have a sufficiently dense concentration of people, for whatever purpose they may be there. This includes people there because of residence.” In dwellings forming a large part of the most cities, concentration of people, who share streets, parks and enterprises of the place, help to generate diversity. Similarly, work, entertainment and other uses must use the city land so intensively and productive that they generate diversity. Then, Jacobs touches on proper densities for city dwellings. Due to the proportionality of density to diversity, the dwelling densities should go as high as they need to go to stimulate the maximum potential diversity in a district. Le Corbusier’s dream city, Radiant City, stands as an example of city dwelling’s high densities with its repetitive skyscrapers in park. Jacobs is against this relocation of people to new buildings by providing green under the name of health and hygiene because in this way, at some point, dwellings are unavoidably standardized as massive high elevator apartments. Jacobs writes that Le Corbusier’s dream city has had an immense impact on our cities. It was appreciated by architects, and has gradually been embodied in projects, ranging from lowincome public housing to office building projects. Nevertheless, for Jane Jacobs, the result was catastrophic. Today, a similar situation continues; contemporary residentials are combined with shopping malls or commercial as different functions. In that case, a housing segregated from commercial means does not have vitality. I think, it can be said these buildings do not contribute to diversity or vitality at all and even make cities monotonous, but many examples of them can be seen in today’s great cities and continue to be constructed. There are good examples as well, nevertheless the examples designed to meet the needs entirely without any architectural and environmental concerns, are truly catastrophic.
In the second part of the book, Jane Jacobs mainly refers how to promote social and economic vitality in cities, yet besides this, I believe that the visual and environmental enhancement is also very crucial for the vitality of a city’s life. Visually, it is needed to beautify cities through designs and achieve aesthetic appeal in a culturally diverse society. Environmentally, human settlements relate to the larger ecosystems of which they are a part. Hence preservation and enhancement of the natural landscape, new open spaces and greening of existing environments are necessary conditions for the revival of the city.
The final section points out some myths about diversity. One of myths is that mix of different uses look ugly and form chaos. Contrarily, they represent a complex and highly developed form of order as against the homogenous places’ disorder of conveying no direction and movement. Rather, homogeneous andstandardized buildings or places invented deliberate distinctions to appear different among others, since they lack the differences coming from different uses. Jacobs asserts that this phenomenon is described by Douglas Haskell as “googie architecture.” Another myth is that mixed uses cause traffic congestion. This is not true. As Jane declares traffic congestion is caused by vehicles, not by people and in diversified city districts people walk. In fact, when there is no mixed use in a district, the use of vehicles will increase, and congestion will occur in order to reach the required use. The final myth mentioned in the book is that mixed uses invite ruinous uses. Jacobs argues some of these uses are harmful, and some are conventionally considered to be harmful but are not. It is defended that junk yards, used-car lots, buildings which have been abandoned or badly underused contributes nothing. Bars, theaters, clinics, businesses and manufacturing are considered harmful, however if these uses are mingled into residential areas, they support other diversity. I think these uses are not harmful either when disperses into other areas than residential as the variety of uses offered meets human needs, support circulation and thereby provide diversity. Also, the book points out that the thin smatterings of nonresidential uses can do harm, because the areas are unequipped to handle strangers to protect them, though citizens and strangers must enjoy security on streets. A secured neighborhood, where people feel safe in its streets, has its own natural hosting storekeeper, doormen, interested neighbors and various users spread time. Another myth is thatparking lots, large or heavy trucking depots, gas stations, gigantic outdoor advertising and enterprises are harmful. They really are because their scale is wrong in a regular city district. These previously mentioned varying uses are the examples of great cities with prospering diversity develop strange and unpredictable uses. This is the whole point of diversity as Jane Jacobs concludes. This is the mission of cities.
Indeed, I strongly think that the book shaped a healthy way to narrate the issue as Jane Jacobs experienced all cases, she gives a place in book, even visited some of them repeatedly, get in contact to people living in cities, and had memories. Jacobs intentionally hopes the book will make readers to skeptically rethink about their own knowledge of cities. I strongly acknowledge the power of design to shape where we live and who we are. The point is we need to learn to apply as much knowledge that is true and useful about cities. Correspondingly, the book, at one point, informed me to see what works well and what does not in the city where I live. Beyond being up to date, it revealed why most of my favorite districts of the city operates perfectly.
References
Jacobs, J. (1961). ‘Part Two: The Conditions for City Diversity’, in The Death and Life of Great American Cities, Random House, New York, pp. 143-238.
Jane Jacobs. (n.d.). Retrieved December 10, 2020, from https://www.britannica.com/biography/Jane-Jacobs
















































