Jane Jacobs’s Ideas on The Conditions for City Diversity: A Review

Jane Jacobs (1916-2006), who is an American-born Canadian journalist, author, social and urban activist, has been published the first of her many books; The Death and Life of Great American Cities in 1961. Jacobs is well-known with her observations on urban life and its problems. The book is consisted of four parts aim to introduce new principles different than the aims shaped modern city planning and rebuilding. Particularly the Part Two: The Conditions for City Diversity, where urbanity, diversity and vitality are discussed thoroughly, will be reviewed in this paper. The life and death of cities is proportional to the question of whether a city is livable or not, because the goal of urban design to create better place to people to live. The chapter is about the places of quality, while the book is a particularly important critic of modernist city as Jane Jacobs was completely against the operations of urban renewal. Indeed, it is a very influential book in urban design and planning. Throughout the book, Jacobs includes her observations, inferences and conclusions on real life of cities, on how cities ought to work and what ought to be good for people and businesses in them. Jacobs harshly criticizes modernist city approach, and certain practices of city planning. At those times, Jane Jacobs did not just passively express her thoughts, but she is also, actively, participated in protests, in which some urban renewal attempts in American cities are objected. It seems to me, her being an activist made her free in her thoughts, therefore she could express her inferences openly.

In general, the book is easily graspable by anyone interested in the ways in which cities operate since Jacobs writes about the things are familiar and held in common. If we can look at the cities we live in with critical eye, if we investigate why the shop under the opposite apartment changes hands many times in a short time, or the dwellings on a street have been vacant for months, how few people passing through the street except residents, how could the 30-storey construction with eight blocks on the side plot find a place there, at some point, we can make sense of this book within ourselves, at least that is what I did. I was able to find examples of many of the issues mentioned in the book from my own circle. Therefore, without hesitation, it can be said that the book, as being a sociological work, appeals to anyone, who observes, can connect with or relate to the general city and street atmosphere in which they live.

While the book generally concentrates on great cities, the problems in planning theory, Part Two and Jacobs (1961) specifically touches on how cities operate, “how cities work in real life and what practices in rebuilding can promote social and economic vitality in cities.” Cities are living organisms that live, transform, change shape over time. Far beyond whether the city that was planned years ago functions well, a plan may not have any of its features designed on a paper. In real life, with the involvement of the user, changing economic conditions, natural environment so on and so forth, city may be operating in a completely different way or it may not be working either anymore. However, the conditions necessary for the functioning of cities do not change but can vary. People come to cities to make use of the advantages of cities, of the diversified opportunities and activities is offers. People come to cities to be able to go theaters, events, exhibitions, concerts and so on. Therefore, cities need a most intricate diversity of uses that give each other continuous support, both economically and socially. “To understand cities, we have to deal outright with combinations or mixtures of uses, not separate uses, as the essential phenomena,” as Jacobs (1961) put forwards, because enough diversity is achieved through the enough mixture among uses. Most of the uses of diversity depend directly or indirectly upon the presence of plentiful and convenient diverse city commerce. This immense number and ranges of small enterprises generated by cities rest on the fact that people need so many different tastes, skills, supplies. To meet the diverse needs of people, cities must offer a certain mixture of activities. Accordingly, “cities have the capability of providing something for everybody, only because, and only when, they are created by everybody,” as Jacobs states. Therefore, the range encompasses grocery stores, pottery schools, movie theatres, candy stores, florists, art shows, galleries, immigrant’s clubs, hardware stores, eating places, and so on mutually support people, each other and city life.

Jacobs proposes that there are four primary conditions required for generating good urban spaces, good diversity in a city’sstreets and districts. These are the needs for primary mixed uses, the need for small blocks, the need for aged buildings, and the need for concentration. By consciously activating these four conditions and blending them together, a city district activates its best potential, vitality.  

First, the need for primary mixed uses. As the first condition of diversity Jacobs (1961) argues that: The district, and indeed as many of its internal parts as possible, must serve more than one primary function: preferably more than two. These must insure the presence of people who go outdoors on different schedules and are in the place for different purposes, but who are able to use many facilities in common. (p. 152)

Offices, factories, dwellings, entertainment and education places, many museums, libraries introduce primary uses which is brought people to that specific place. However, to diversify and revive cities, it is needed a secondary use to combined with primary use that puts people on the street at different times. Here, Jane Jacobs (1961) mentions that “on successful city streets, people must appear at different times,”and adds that the significance of time spread can be seen clearly at the district embracing Wall Street in Manhattan, which is a district suffering from extreme time unbalance among its users. This situation is observable during the day. At weekday noon, a dense crowd of people going out for lunch taking up huge areas, while after five p.m. and weekends there is full silence. However, the district ought to offer other uses than business and spread people through time of day and serve mixed primary uses. Then, as attempts to revitalize the city with second uses, part of the district’s waterfront can be transformed into a marine museum or to build a new aquarium to the waterfront, as Jacobs proposes. This would liven up the district during weekends. Additionally, to revive a city, I think design of public spaces play a crucial role, because they provide communication, enjoyment and relaxation unlike routines of work and home. With street performances, protests, festivals, open markets and other interesting activity, public spaces can attract people and tourists who may then become good customers for retail business. This may be related to the tempo of the city; various uses increase the tempo. On the other hand, the pace of some cities is so low that I feel like I am not going to survive. How could the city not die?

Second, the need for small blocks. Here, Jacobs looks closely at how streets are working in vibrant urban district, then she (1961) asserts the second condition for city diversity which is “most blocks must be short; that is, streets and opportunities to turn corners must be frequent”.Long street blocks restrict the opportunities that would be offered by the street corner. They would cause separated and isolated long paths until reach a place where pool of use is formed, where people come together in one stream. I see that going the same way to a main axis, where all uses are gathered, brings monotony and dullness to the city and life, so cities still need alternative routes that offer various uses for the vitality to sustain. Having an extra street cutting across the long blocks allows creation of frequent streets and short blocks mixing with one another and then siting parks, squares, and public buildings at key locations. She concluded that a mixture of uses must be supported by frequent streets.  Rockefeller Center in New York City, which provides new uses by adding streets cutting long blocks, is a particularly good example as Jacobs evokes in the book. It seems to me; Rockefeller center is also the prototype to produce diversity through the public space.  

Third, the need for aged buildings. Jacobs (1961) suggest that “the district must mingle buildings that vary in age and condition, including a good proportion of old ones.” If we were talking about Roman city example, the aged buildings would gain importance in a quite different context, but in the case of America, Jacobs’ arguments for preserving old buildings are primarily economic and social rather than aesthetic or historical. Great cities are needed mix of buildings varying in age and condition. If a district consists only of new buildings, then only uses that can afford these economically can exist there whereas Jacobs mentions many times that diversity means the existence of various small uses, small enterprises. Thus, old buildings are crucial for enterprises that have a share in generating diversity but cannot afford high prices. Old buildings also offer low-cost housing. Besides economic concerns there is another dimension; heterogeneity, which buildings varying age and condition bring into open. Such heterogeneity might have ability to attract people to a specific district, I think. Another thing Jane Jacobs inference is that wiping out old buildings and constructing great swatches at one time is inevitably inefficient since populations and business prefer districts in which diversity is created through a good mix of buildings. In a vital city district that meets people needs, the brilliant adaptations and minor changes, where stable becomes house, or the garage becomes a theater, or the butcher shop becomes a restaurant occurs forever which is nice. Jacobs exemplifies that no building is underrated in New York City’s Greenwich Village as it is a successful district, on the other hand, in Miami Beach hotels ten years old are considered aged, and I think they are having aesthetic concerns, and are lost because others are newer and the new is the ruler there.  

Fourth, the need for concentration. Jacobs observes a sufficiently dense concentration of people is necessary to enhance city diversity and asserts (1961) that “the district must have a sufficiently dense concentration of people, for whatever purpose they may be there. This includes people there because of residence.” In dwellings forming a large part of the most cities, concentration of people, who share streets, parks and enterprises of the place, help to generate diversity. Similarly, work, entertainment and other uses must use the city land so intensively and productive that they generate diversity. Then, Jacobs touches on proper densities for city dwellings. Due to the proportionality of density to diversity, the dwelling densities should go as high as they need to go to stimulate the maximum potential diversity in a district. Le Corbusier’s dream city, Radiant City, stands as an example of city dwelling’s high densities with its repetitive skyscrapers in park. Jacobs is against this relocation of people to new buildings by providing green under the name of health and hygiene because in this way, at some point, dwellings are unavoidably standardized as massive high elevator apartments. Jacobs writes that Le Corbusier’s dream city has had an immense impact on our cities. It was appreciated by architects, and has gradually been embodied in projects, ranging from lowincome public housing to office building projects. Nevertheless, for Jane Jacobs, the result was catastrophic. Today, a similar situation continues; contemporary residentials are combined with shopping malls or commercial as different functions. In that case, a housing segregated from commercial means does not have vitality. I think, it can be said these buildings do not contribute to diversity or vitality at all and even make cities monotonous, but many examples of them can be seen in today’s great cities and continue to be constructed. There are good examples as well, nevertheless the examples designed to meet the needs entirely without any architectural and environmental concerns, are truly catastrophic.

In the second part of the book, Jane Jacobs mainly refers how to promote social and economic vitality in cities, yet besides this, I believe that the visual and environmental enhancement is also very crucial for the vitality of a city’s life. Visually, it is needed to beautify cities through designs and achieve aesthetic appeal in a culturally diverse society. Environmentally, human settlements relate to the larger ecosystems of which they are a part. Hence preservation and enhancement of the natural landscape, new open spaces and greening of existing environments are necessary conditions for the revival of the city.

The final section points out some myths about diversity. One of myths is that mix of different uses look ugly and form chaos. Contrarily, they represent a complex and highly developed form of order as against the homogenous places’ disorder of conveying no direction and movement. Rather, homogeneous andstandardized buildings or places invented deliberate distinctions to appear different among others, since they lack the differences coming from different uses. Jacobs asserts that this phenomenon is described by Douglas Haskell as “googie architecture.” Another myth is that mixed uses cause traffic congestion. This is not true. As Jane declares traffic congestion is caused by vehicles, not by people and in diversified city districts people walk. In fact, when there is no mixed use in a district, the use of vehicles will increase, and congestion will occur in order to reach the required use. The final myth mentioned in the book is that mixed uses invite ruinous uses. Jacobs argues some of these uses are harmful, and some are conventionally considered to be harmful but are not. It is defended that junk yards, used-car lots, buildings which have been abandoned or badly underused contributes nothing. Bars, theaters, clinics, businesses and manufacturing are considered harmful, however if these uses are mingled into residential areas, they support other diversity. I think these uses are not harmful either when disperses into other areas than residential as the variety of uses offered meets human needs, support circulation and thereby provide diversity. Also, the book points out that the thin smatterings of nonresidential uses can do harm, because the areas are unequipped to handle strangers to protect them, though citizens and strangers must enjoy security on streets. A secured neighborhood, where people feel safe in its streets, has its own natural hosting storekeeper, doormen, interested neighbors and various users spread time. Another myth is thatparking lots, large or heavy trucking depots, gas stations, gigantic outdoor advertising and enterprises are harmful. They really are because their scale is wrong in a regular city district. These previously mentioned varying uses are the examples of great cities with prospering diversity develop strange and unpredictable uses. This is the whole point of diversity as Jane Jacobs concludes. This is the mission of cities. 

Indeed, I strongly think that the book shaped a healthy way to narrate the issue as Jane Jacobs experienced all cases, she gives a place in book, even visited some of them repeatedly, get in contact to people living in cities, and had memories. Jacobs intentionally hopes the book will make readers to skeptically rethink about their own knowledge of cities. I strongly acknowledge the power of design to shape where we live and who we are. The point is we need to learn to apply as much knowledge that is true and useful about cities. Correspondingly, the book, at one point, informed me to see what works well and what does not in the city where I live. Beyond being up to date, it revealed why most of my favorite districts of the city operates perfectly.

References

Jacobs, J. (1961). ‘Part Two: The Conditions for City Diversity’, in The Death and Life of Great American Cities, Random House, New York, pp. 143-238.

Jane Jacobs. (n.d.). Retrieved December 10, 2020, from https://www.britannica.com/biography/Jane-Jacobs

Learning in Museums: The Physical Context

Introduction

Museums objectively exhibit, store and protect. Another concept that unites museum settings in common is learning. Besides museum’s role of displaying and objective of sharing exhibitions with public, the whole dimensions of the museum also support the mission of learning. As Falk and Dierking (2000) asserted museums provide the intersection of the personal, sociocultural, and physical contexts of learning. In a wide range of fields representing the physical, social, and personal dimensions of museum environments; the paper takes stock of research on museums as learning institutions and uses the term “museums” to include facilities such as history museum, art museum, science-technology centers, aquarium, planetariums, and zoos.

Under the main title of “learning in the museum context”; firstly, the personal context that refers to what individualities a visitor bring to the museum is clarifies. Secondly, the social context, explaining how museums communicate with the surrounding population through their collection, exhibitions and events (Dodd as cited in Dias & César, 2014) and promote the communication and exploration of users, is explained. Thirdly, the physical context comprises the physical aspects of the museum environment, including the labels, and architectural features such as colors, texture and so on. The paper essentially takes the physical context into consideration and explains what and how the physical design features of the museum environment influences visitor’s learning. 

Resulting from realizing that for learning it is important to provide visitors environmental satisfaction, well-being and well-designed spaces at a point, later on, the study is devoted to research on the physical properties of the exhibition space and how they affect the user in general.

Learning in The Museum Context

Museums should be in the position of institutions, which put the concept of learning very well into function because museums are separated from official learning spaces and didactic teaching opportunities they offered. Museums actually exists not just to fulfill the function of display and teach the history, ruins from ancient times, scientific discoveries, art, but it also takes on the task of being usually socializing leisure-oriented, cultural center. Today, visitors do not necessarily come to a museum to learn. And museums do not solely exist to teach (Knutson, & Crowley, 2005). Visitors go to museums to have fun, leave the museum reaping the benefit of what they have learned and gained from their experience. Therefore, learning experiences in museums involve people interacting with other people, or with objects and artifacts, in some kind of learning environment, and using socially constructed language (Falk, J. H., Dierking, L. D., & Foutz, S., 2007).  

Figure 1 The Contextual Model of Learning (Source: Falk and Dierking 2000, p.12)

Falk and Dierking (1992, 2000) proposed that three contexts –the personal, social and physical- interact to produce the nature and outcomes of the visitor’s museum experience. The interaction and the cooperation of personal social and physical aspects construct the context of museums. The cumulative gaining of these contexts over time constitutes the museum experience at the junction. They evolve and exist together through time, and then there occurs experience in the center of and in a dialogue with these three surrounding dimensions. The experience influences learning in museum environments. As Falk and Dierking (1992) mentioned learning is the process of applying prior knowledge and experience to new experiences; this effort is normally played out within a physical context and is mediated in the actions of other individuals. 

Personal Context

Each museum visitor bring to the museum what they carry in terms of prior knowledge, variety of experience, interest, motivations, concerns, social skills and this history influence individuals’ learning in museums. These characteristics also mean that each person arrives at the museum with a personal agenda –a set of expectations and anticipated outcomes for the visit (Falk, J. H., & Dierking, L. D., 2013). Therefore, from a personal context perspective, learning can be expected to be proportional to the motivation and expectations of the individual. Correspondingly, most learning that occurs in museums has more to do with consolidation and reinforcement of previously understood ideas than with the creation of totally new knowledge structures (Falk, J.,1999), a study was carried in World of Life exhibition organized in the California Science Center by John H. Falk. Visitors, who had current understanding about the information on display before start visiting, were able to demonstrate a significantly greater understanding of the subject matter after completing their visit. Study reveals just how these exhibitions personally constructed each visitor’s learning as learning is the act of adapting existing pre knowledge and experience to new experience. Visit strengthened what a visitor already knew, and their knowledge were changed and developed as a consequence of the visit. 

Social Context

Museum visitation is, to a large extent, a social experience (Bitgood, 2002). Museums are social environments where visitors can be involved and take active role in interactions and they offer rich social and leisure time experiences where social interactions, visitor engagement in activities play an important role in learning opportunities. The interaction among individuals forms the social context of museums. The sharing and communication of people with the social group they are involved in – i.e. tourist group, school group, family, friends- continues within the museum, group members discuss ideas among themselves, share ideas with pleasure, and enjoy learning. Corresponding with the interactions with others, the museum experience may differ depending on whether one walks through a museum with an eighteen-year-old or with an eightyear-old in tow; whether one is a parent with two small children; or whether or not one’s companion is knowledgeable about the exhibits (Falk, J.,1999). Regarding how shared and individual knowledge might be transformed by the discussion, a study was carried by Bitgood and Patterson (1987) on how the presence and behavior of other people influences visitors’ behavior or activity. It was found that feeding at a monkey usually occurred in a chain of individuals feeding the animals immediately after one person started. More people experience from the experience of another person and contribute to the museum learning of the visitors. This is how visitors are influenced by surrounding connections.

Physical Context

The physical context consists of the settings of the museum. Not only does physical setting create a context in which learning can occur, but physical settings also have the potential to create a desire for learning (Falk, J. H., & Dierking, L. D., 2000). A space is experienced by the individuals as a whole including scale, proportions, textures, colors, sights, materials, lighting, furniture, acoustics, and heat. Since a well-designed interior is effective in strengthening the perception of visitors, foster curiosity and encourage exploration, interior and architectural design decisions are very important. How visitors behave, what they observe, and what they remember is strongly influenced by the physical context. How can the angles, framings and colors of walls, promote curiosity and wonder? How can the lighting influence experience? These might the investigation on how specific design features in the museum context might support, guide, or even inhibit learning.

The physical context effects occur at various levels ranging from the micro level physical context to the macro level physical context. The micro level context refers to the exhibition, design elements of exhibits, labels and objects contained within an exhibition. Considerable research has focused on the exhibitions and labels; their sequencing, density, positioning, and content since they are designed to be the primary teaching tool within museums. Besides, macro level physical context attributes to spaces, places, architectural design factors such as shape, proportion, scale, texture, lighting, color, sound, material, window size, and so on. At the macrolevel, perception of physical spaces as, for example, open and friendly or dark and menacing, influences one’s sense of well-being and security, which in turn affects ability to learn (Falk, J. H., & Dierking, L. D.,2013). Since learning considerably associates with the visitor experience satisfaction, satisfaction from the physical context well-being, pleasantness, and engagement to a great extent, from this point on, learning activity in a museum space will be interpreted and discussed through the design of interior spaces and through how human perceives interior spaces, how they react; whether positive or not, curious or bored.

Space

Spaces are the environments that surround our body, which contribute to our being comfortable or uncomfortable, happy or unhappy (İmamoğlu, V., İmamoğlu, E. O., İmamoğlu, Ç., 2017). Space is created by the design and the visitor experience is influenced by the creation of space. Space is actually a context, a creation which has a possibility to affect individuals in many aspects; in museums, visitors get used to and affected by what the space and its quality offers for them.  With its design, a space either draws the visitor in or not, challenges them or comforts them. Each space design is a complex whole with its defined shape and scale, dimensions, light, acoustics, furniture, color and texture of the materials on its surfaces (İmamoğlu, V., İmamoğlu, E. O., İmamoğlu, Ç., 2017).

Shape, mass and form 

The primary tools for creating space are shape and mass. Spaces consist of twodimensional shapes of floor, wall, and ceiling planes and door and window openings that enclose space, and this framework builds a sense of mass. Shape and mass affect the person’s perception of space. For example, it has been observed that spaces with a square and near square plan are perceived as larger, free and better planned compared to the spaces having long rectangle plan (İmamoğlu, V., İmamoğlu, E. O., İmamoğlu, Ç., 2017). 

Spaces are perceived as forms and forms have definite of size, color, and texture in addition to shape. Forms as well as the other design elements can be manipulated in ways that either promote exploration and curiosity, or do not and accordingly satisfy visitor needs. Stewart  classifies forms of space as curvilinear, cubic or irregular and etc. (Stewart as cited in Safavi, S., 2013). For example, in Figure 2, Frank Llody Wright’s Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum has a curvilinear form of exhibition space together with its curved walls.

Frank Llody Wright’s Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum. Curvilinear Form of Space (Source: Laurian Ghinitoiu).
(a) CerModern Arts Center, Curvilienar Form of Space. (b) White Cube Contemportary Art Gallery, Cubic Form of Space. (c) Danish Jewish Museum, Irregular Form of Space. (Sources: Uygur Architects, Paul Riddle, Bitter Bredt respectively)

In Figure 3, CerModern Arts Center stands out with its curvilinear form of exhibition space, and the rounded skylight opening supports its form. White Cube Contemporary Arch Gallery has its regular structural rhythm and creates a cubic form of space with its rectangle plan drawing, walls and ceiling. Danish Jewish Museum is an example for irregular form of space without following an order, or having architectural elements with defined size and proportion.

Proportion and scale

Proportion and scale are also important design elements. While size determines the proportions of a form, its scale is determined by its size relative to other forms in its context (Ching, 2007). Museum display and interpret objects, events or even ideas, all of which must be presented within appropriate proportion and scale to each other and to the larger physical context in which they are embedded, the museum (Falk, J. H., & Dierking, L. D., 2000). The balance and relative size of exhibit objects within the museum space has impact on visitor attention and interest in exhibitions. For example, an exhibition object can be perceived as both small and large, depending on the size of the space they are displayed in. 

In order to use scale principle effectively, there is a crucial need to a common standard. Human form is accepted widely as a standard (Lauer & Pentak, 1995). The scale of the exhibit space compared to the size of the human body is affective regarding the spatial dimensions of bodily experience. Additionally, scale could enhance emotional and perceptual aspects of a building’s interior space. For example, very high ceiling in comparison with human size might make a sense of fear.  

Inside Paris’s Orsay Museum. (b) Louvre Museum Cour Marly.  (Source: Getty Images/Atlantide
Phototravel as cited in Architectural Digest, Michel Denancé, respectively)

Proportion helps to the designer to construct a stable set of visual relationships among individual components, the components to the whole building and between the whole composition and its context (Salyan & Thapa as cited in Safavi, 2013). The design that is out of proportion gives negative feeling to viewer. In Figure 4, Safavi (2013) interprets the Orsay Museum as its walls are built in different height; the skylight is separated from walls by applying different color and the interior of building has been built in different levels. These ratios between different levels have been made visitors wouldn’t feel the long height of building and to feel more comfortable. Similarly, in Cour Marly courtyard of Louvre Museum, although the place is very imposing and has high ceilings, the museum visitor does not feel fear in this size thanks to the proper proportional relation between the architectural elements and exhibition objects on the floor, and they can enjoy the museum as it exists on its own scale.

Texture

Texture is the look and feel of the surface. Texture is the first thing that a user perceives so it influences his/her experience of that space (Lauer & Pentak, 1995). A user’s perception on texture could be categorized in two groups: physically and visually. Texture can vary physically, such that the surface is rough or smooth, hard or soft, bristly or velvety. This gives different feelings to the users. The texture can also vary visually; through light and shadow, the appearance of the surface can undulate or shine or appear dappled (Falk, J. H., & Dierking, L. D., 2018).  

Erimtan Archaeology and Arts Museum Texture Details (Source: Onur Yüncü Architecture)

Textures and patterns can evoke emotional responses. Smooth textures seem “cold,” while rough textures such as created by shag rugs, plush fabrics, and uneven wall surfaces contribute to a sense of “warmth” in interior spaces (Falk, J. H., & Dierking, L. D., 2018). As in Figure 6, the warmth coming from the soft wooden texture of architectural elements and the hard smooth wall surfaces creates a balance within the exhibition hall. Additionally, carpeting the floor of a museum can lessen the fatigue that visitors experience by giving the feeling of warm, while rough floors arouse the feeling of cold on users. While multi-pattern texture can visually confuse and cause distraction, thoughtfulness and fatigue, an object surrounded by a neutral, still pattern gives calmness and highlights the object.

Odunpazarı Modern Museum Interior (Source: NAARO)

Moreover, seeing the repetition of a pattern elsewhere can remind the visitor of the previous position, the previous object, in fact, it makes the visitor look again and again. In this context, establishing relations increases the visitor engagement with the museum interior. Texture and pattern, along with the tools of visual unity and variety, as well as emphasis, balance, and rhythm, allow designers to manipulate where the eye is drawn and how the visitor will respond to an exhibition (Falk, J. H., & Dierking, L. D., 2018). Thus, the intended feelings can be given to the users by designing the texture.

Color

Color is considered as a key element of exhibition design. Color is able to manipulate individuals’ moods and feelings. Its impact is more than aesthetic; it is also emotional, cultural, and, of course, reflective of learned preferences and experiences. Designers use color to highlight, to emphasize, and ideally, to communicate key feelings and messages (Falk, J. H., & Dierking, L. D., 2018).  Color is the attribute that most clearly distinguishes a form from its environment. When entering an exhibition hall, the harmony of the colors of the materials used, being striking, and individual’s perception of hue, saturation, tonal values are affective on how users feel the building. 

Soumaya Museum Exhibition Hall (Source: Adam Weisman)

Proper color selection should result in proper presentation of the object importance (Benya & Karlen, 2004). For example, in Figure 8, applying white color to surfaces as background of exhibition objects make them more visible. In addition, it makes the space to be perceived bigger. On the contrary it is clearly observable that using warm colors has given a warm feeling to the space but makes the object difficult to perceive. 

Conclusion

The field of museum studies, in particular Falk and Dierking’s framework, emphasizes the importance of good design supporting visitor learning in creative and compelling ways. A well-designed physical context of space helps visitors to make sense of their world, and support their inquiry and curiosity. Museums promote experiential learning by providing spaces for meaning making, for exploration; opportunities for dialogue, debate, and connection; access to thought-provoking, relevant content and surrounding, experiences; and more. Furthermore, the harmony and integrity among the visitor and space, significantly affect the perception of that space. 

Paying attention to the ways in which learning occurs in exhibits and spaces is critical to design affective spaces. These ways, search and principles makes it able to guide museum design consciously and improve learning considering the environmental design in museum areas.

References

Bitgood, S., & Patterson, D. (1987). Principles of exhibit design. Visitor Behavior, Vol 2.

Bitgood, S., & Patterson, D. (1987). Some Evolving Principles of Visitor Behavior.

Bitgood, S. (1993). The Anatomy of An Exhibit. Visitor Behavior, Vol, 7.

Bitgood, S. (2002).  Environmental Psychology in Museums, Zoos, and Other Exhibition

Centers. Handbook of Environmental Psychology, John Wiley & Sons. Pp. 461-480.

Bitgood, S. (2014). Exhibition Design that Provides High Value and Engages Visitor Attention. The exhibitionist.

Ching, F. D. K. (2007). Architecture: Form, space, & order. Hoboken, N.J: John Wiley & Sons.

Dias, A. & César, M. (2014). Museums as spaces and times for learning and social participation.  Psychology in Russia: State of the Art. 

Falk, J.H., & Dierking, L.D. (1997). School Field Trips: Assessing Their LongTerm Impact.

Falk, J. (1999). Museums as Institutions for Personal Learning. Daedalus, 128(3), 259-275. 

Falk, J. H., & Dierking, L. D. (2000). Learning from museums: Visitor experiences and the making of meaning. Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press.

Falk, J. H., & Storksdieck, M. (2005). Using the Contextual Model of Learning to Understand Visitor Learning from a Science Center Exhibition. Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Sci Ed  89: 744–778, 2005

Falk, J. H., Dierking, L. D., & Foutz, S. (2007). In principle, in practice: Museums as learning institutions. Lanham: AltaMira Press. chapter5 , rennie, Johnston pp.60

Falk, J. H., & Dierking, L. D. (2013). The museum experience revisited. Walnut Creek, Calif: Left Coast Press, Inc.

Falk, J. H., & Dierking, L. D. (2018). Learning from museums.

İmamoğlu, V., İmamoğlu, E. O., İmamoğlu, Ç. (2017). Mimarlık ve Psikoloji İlişkisi Üzerine.

Kelly, L. (2010). Engaging Museum Visitors in Difficult Topics Through Socio-cultural Learning and Narrative.

Knutson, K., & Crowley, K. (2005). Museum as learning laboratory: Developing and using a practical theory of informal learning. Hand to Hand.  (Part1 of 2) 18(4), pp. 4-5.

Lauer, D. A., & Pentak, S. (1995). Design basics. Fort Worth: Harcourt Brace College Publishers.

Leinhardt, G., Knutson, K., & Crowley, K. (2003). Museum Learning Colloborative Redux. The Journal of Museum Education, 28(1), 23-31. 

Safavi, S. (2013). Effects of Design Principles on Visitor’s Perception in Museum Space. Eastern Mediterranean University, North Cyprus.

Yılmazsoy, A. C., (2005). Visitor Behavior in Museum Environments: An Analysis of Visitor Circulation Patterns in Sadberk Hanım Museum. Interior Architecture and Environmental Design and The Institute of Fine Arts of Bilkent University, Ankara.

Volumes in Building Scale: “Volumes as opposed to Mass”

volume analysis

This is a text seeks the volumetric representation of buildings as three- dimensional forms comprising length, width, and depth, as volumes in which International Style is based on.

Hitchcock and Johnson delineated the first principle of the International Style as “Architecture as Volume”. On the subject of volume, Goldhagen mentions the intention of the style: “…They (modernist buildings) are shaped by an orientation toward volume rather than mass, except when space takes second place to innovations in program, materials, systems, and so on…”

“…Style is character, style is expression; but even character must be displayed and expression may be conscious and clear, or muddled and deceptive. The architect who builds in the international style seeks to display the true character of his construction and to express clearly his provision for function. He (the architect) prefers such an organization of his general composition, such a use of available surface materials, and such a handling of detail as will increase rather than contradict the prime effect of surface of volume.”

Before anything else it is better to mention which elements the volume relates to. Since international style upholds the radical simplification of form, what is a form? Apart from the theories of form (conceptual foundations), ranging from the notion that forms are generated within the creative imagination to the notion that they derive from function and climate, form defined by Ching as the shape and structure of something distinguished from its substance or material. The way form is created, constructed, or organized along with other forms is often governed by a certain discipline which is called “structure” by Wucius Wong. Similarly, Vitruvius, in his De Architectura Libri Decem, had considered the structural framework as a precondition of architectural form. Form suggests reference to both internal structure and external outline and the principle that gives unity to the whole.

“Vitruvius’ conception of the source of form emerges in his account of how primitive men created the first shelters. The first men improved first experiments by observing the shelters of others and adding new details to their own inceptions, and by modifying constructional forms and details, which failed in winter storms. The original source of form, then, was found first in experiments with building materials, then in adaptation and refinement as climate and use tested and the shelters, and also in imitation of successful shelters elsewhere. The source of form is thoroughly embedded in the physical world itself and owes nothing to an extra- sensory divine overseer. (Gelemter, 1995)”

Form usually refers to the principle that gives unity to a whole, and often includes a sense of mass or volume. If we start by introducing volume, form is the primary identifying characteristic of a volume. It is established by the shapes and interrelationships of the planes that describe the boundaries of the volume. Considering that a more detailed explanation is appropriate for understanding shapes and planes that helps to depict the perimeters of a volume, the next two paragraphs will address them.

Shape refers more specifically to the essential aspect of form that governs its appearance the configuration or relative disposition of the lines or contours that delimit a figure or form. The primary shapes can be extended or rotated to generate volumetric forms or solids that are distinct, regular, and easily recognizable. Form in this sense is not just a shape that is seen, but a shape of definite size, color, and texture (visual elements).

Architectural forms can be broken down into four element types: points, lines, planes, and volumes (conceptual elements). Points, moving through space and define lines, lines define planes. Since architecture, as a visual art, deals specifically with the formation of three-dimensional volumes of form, the plane becomes a key element in the vocabulary of architectural design. Planes extend in a direction other than its intrinsic direction becomes three-dimensional volumes of form. In the formation of a visual construction, a plane serves to define the limits or boundaries of a volume. About the form and the conceptual elements, the conceptual elements are not visible. They do not exist physically, but are perceived as being present. Thus point, line or plane, when visible, becomes form.

Going back to understand the volume, it is a good way to understand the intention of International Style about volume, here is what the architects following the style comprehend: “The modern architect working in the new style (The International Style) conceives of his building not as a structure of brick or masonry with thick columns and supporting walls resting heavily upon the earth but rather as a skeleton enclosed by a thin light shell. He (architect) thinks in terms of volume— of space enclosed by planes or surfaces — as opposed to mass and solidity. This principle of volume leads him to make his walls seem thin flat surfaces by eliminating moldings and by making his windows and doors flush with the surface.” While this remark supports volume formation with planes on the one hand, it also touches on volume being different than mass and solidity on the other hand. In this regard, Ching declares following: As the three-dimensional element in the vocabulary of architectural design, a volume can be either a solid—space displaced by mass—or a void—space contained or enclosed by planes. Solid volumes contain mass, while void volumes contain space surrounded by planes. In architecture, a volume can be seen to be either a portion of space contained and defined by wall, floor, and ceiling or roof planes, or a quantity of space displaced by the mass of building.

In a sense, mass of building is a unified composition of two-dimensional shapes or three dimensional volumes, esp. one that has or gives the impression of weight, density, and bulk. In his book: Towards a New Architecture, Le Corbusier mentions the mass as one of the elements by which architecture manifests itself since the architectural elements with the parts they occupied create the building mass. His one of three reminders to architects is mass. Mass is determined by the plan. The plan is the generator. The whole structure rises from its base and is developed in accordance with a rule which is written on the ground in the plan: noble forms, variety of form, and unity of the geometric principle. This is mass with all these elements. Without plan there can be neither grandeur of aim and expression, nor rhythm, nor mass, nor coherence. The plan is what determines everything; it is the decisive moment.

At this point, mass being determined by the plan and the volume production using the plan is correlated. Therefore, rather than commenting on buildings about the duality Ching mentions, buildings are perceived and then reproduced as quantity of space displaced by the mass of building by reading and making use of original orthographic plans, elevations and sections and first hand experiences. To initialize the building volume, the process started with defining the void building blocks, the basic volume of the building massing. The shape of the volume and its dimension is defined by exterior surfaces in the x- and y-directions and the building height in the z-direction. The volume is seen without included or determined elements, as empty spaces filled with air. Of course, the details, the architectural elements taking place on facades were abstracted to a certain extent. Solid planes in same color generate the volume without ambiguity, and they offer depth.

Thus, the regularity and diversity within the unity, coherency, integration and wholeness of essential volumes which embody the campus buildings can be explored infinitely… These, the volumetric representations of spaces, display that the order among the volumes creates “unity as well as variety”.


Bibliography

Barr, A. H., Hitchcock, H.-R., Johnson, P., Mumford, L., & Museum of Modern Art (New York, N.Y.). (1932). Modern architecture: International exhibition, New York, Feb. 10 to March 23, 1932, Museum of Modern Art. New York: Museum of Modern Art.

Ching, F, D.K (1995). A Visual Dictionary of Architecture, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York.

Ching, F. D. K. (2007). Architecture: Form, space, & order. Hoboken, N.J: John Wiley & Sons.

Gelemter, M (1995). Sources of Architectural Form (A Critical History of Western Design Theory), Manchester University Press, Manchester and New York.

Goldhagen, S. (2005). Something to Talk about: Modernism, Discourse, Style. Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians, 64(2), 144-167. doi:10.2307/25068142

Henry-Russell Hitchcock, Jr., and Philip Johnson (1932). The International Style: Architecture Since 1922. New York, W. W. Norton & Co.

Le, C. (1986). Towards a new architecture. New York: Dover Publications.

Wong, W. (1972). Principles of Two-Dimensional Design. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold Co.

Yılmaz, S. (1999), Evolution of the Architectural Form Based on the Geometrical Concepts. İzmir Institute of Technology izmir, Turkey.

initial proposal

As a continuation of analyses has been made in a large scale, the project’s initial proposal shaped following the previously shaped ideas. There are two main points I have hold onto while initiating the process; 1. to strengthen the relationship between sea & land, as an inverse of the corelation of sea and land in Kaleiçi district, insteas of getting the sea inside of the land, the land or the mass should go above the sea. 2. Talya hotel blocks both the view, access and the prevailing wind coming from the sea, so there should be an access through the sea from the road level to give an answer to ecological concerns and provide permability. So, considering the created axes following the already existed roads and Talya Hotel’s used angles, there occured some imaginary paths to guide visitors and position masses then spaces according to the program input. Hereby, Talya’s wings like separated elements and some connective elements in between came into existence as an initial proposal. In this instance, they are standing like quickly defined rectangle masses just to initiate the process, further on when the site conditions, ecological concerns, program, and user profiles introduced to the process, the project will take shape accordingly and more defined definetely.

starting the process

In the historical context, the coast has been evaluated in different dimensions in different time periods and by human beings. The coast has been tried to participate in urban life by using the opportunities it offers.

Actually, the sea or coast creates a living culture when it is considered in terms of it shapes the citizens’ or the city’s living style, and give a culture to the city together with the historical symbols. There is this Kaleiçi culture that introduce such a city identity where people’s memories and expectations come into existence. Especially this collective memory of the city in Kaleiçi gives people the feeling of creating a bridge among previous historical times, today and perhaps future like different periods in one space.

Here, what I want to emphasize is Talya Hotel is one of the identities & symbols of the city as well, but more in a contemporary manner like in terms of being first five starred hotel in Antalya. So, the purpose is making the coast region the focus of urban life (in a more modern way).

Plus, coastal region section types is analyzed: how is the relationship between land and sea along the coastline? #1 pedestrian priority coast region use (limited communication, inability to meet with the coast outside the visual perception) due to the location of the tourism structures and the presence of highways, the city’s relation to the sea and its continuity is weak. (not in Kaleiçi district, the sea is accessible along the port region) #2 public areas & functions along the coast.

In the upper-scale analysis, I don’t want Talya to turn its back to the urban life & an introduced side street in between the wings of Talya Hotel allowed to create interrelation, coastal interface as seen in plan drawing.

Analysis of Antalya — Antalya’s Natural and Ecological Context

After 1950, Antalya started to receive immigration. Since 1980, this amount of immigration has increased considerably. The main reason for this sudden increase is tourism in this region. The population of Muratpaşa is higher than other regions, although the area is smaller than other ones. Here we see the change in population, in 10 years. […]

Analysis of Antalya — An archıtecture student’s Journey

state of the mediterranean marine and coastal environment

click for larger image in details

Mediterranean marine and coastal environment is examined under the main titles of Aquaculture and its production in the Mediterranean. Although mediterranean region has a long history fish farming, aquaculture -which is the fastest growing food sector in the world- and particularlly mariculture have undergone a dramatic expansion since 1990s.

Mediterranean sea is the prototype of a semi-enclosed sea with a limited connection to the ocean through a narrow and shallow strait. Infographics which refers to surface circulation, river discharge of freshwater into the Mediterranean. Schematically shows the mediterranean sea water masses: vertical distribution since the mediterranean sea comprises three main water masses.

There you can see infographics which shows maritime transportation routes in the mediterranean and coastal transport infrastructure in the mediterranean since the development of maritime transport is inherently linked to the development of coastal infrastructure such as ports and motorways and railways connnecting in land areas to the ports.

The mediterranean basin, is by far the largest global tourism destionation, attracting almost a third of the world’s internationsl tourists and besides, tourism contributes CO2 emissions, mostly thorugh increased use of air and road transportation. About the tourism in the mediterranean countries, there is a scheme which shows international tourism receipts share via countries, and tourist pressure on mediterranean coast again via countries.

An overview of water stress in the mediterranean basin, water exploitation, geography, physiography and landscapes, coastal erosion and fragial ecosystems in the mediterranean.

The image above contains, graphics about litter, industrial hazardous waste in the mediterranean countries, floating plastics, plastic pellets, and organic micropollutants; neo-renewable energy resources; major types of marine litter; sources of environmental impact on the mediterranean sea. Additionally, organic water pollutants, the amount of the oil spilled in the mediterranean, possible oil slicks detected by satelllites.

Infographical maps which shows mean surface salinity, total annual precipitations and sea level variations.

Maritime transportation and aquaculture are the main ways non-indigenous specied enter the western basin of the mediterranean. Migration through the Suez Canal is responsible for most non-indigenous species in the eastern basin of mediterranean. Mediterranean sea is a biodiversity hotspot containing large amount of marine species, nearly a quarter of which are endemic. There exists maps refers to biodiversity in meditetteranean, number of species in the image above.

Climatically, the mediterranean is characterised by warm temperatures, winter dominated rainfall, dry summers, and an abundance of microclimates. The sea surface temperature, mean annual & surface temperature of the mediterranean is added as well.

Please click the to the link below the image to get more detailed information.

Reference: Mediterranean Marine and Coastal Environment in http://www.grida.no/resources/5937

Mediterranean Institute of Oceanography, Antalya

This term’s project topic is Mediterranean Institute of Oceanography. The project site is located on a cliffed shore in Antalya’s Muratpaşa district on which Talya Hotel is situated. Talya Hotel was operated between 1975-2013 as the first five star hotel in Antalya, it remains idle now. The MIO which is going to be located in the site of Talya Hotel, as an Oceanographic center, will have multi-functional programmatic structure and the location of the site has great potential to contribute to the urban life of Antalya.

Visual Culture

I would like to start by mentioning the concepts and approaches I have inspired from while producing the architectural representation above.

At one hand, there can be talked about the concept of tabula rasa where the city was seen as tabula rasa as a zero ground, clear surface to brand new start. Here, what important is the movement rather than settlement so that it is about redefining, planning and designing the human movement in city rather than sticking the existing. On the other hand, in architecture, there are the approach of the ‘As Found’ by Alison and Peter Smithson from Independent Group. They argue “…Setting ourselves the task of rethinking architecture in the early 1950s, we meant by the “as found” not only adjacent buildings but all those marks that constitute remembrancers in a place and that are to be read through finding out how the existing built fabric of the place had come to be as it was.”  (Smithsons, 1990) “Hence, they noted that the respect for the existing ‘structuring’ of a site must be equal to our respect for the mature trees. They touched the terminology of ‘as found’ as to make it specific-to-place.” (Smithsons, 1990) That was related with old, critical regionalism, vernacular architecture, local qualities, values and so on.  

“In 1953, Alison and Peter Smithson presented their entry for the Golden Lane bombed neighbourhood at the ninth congress of CIAM.” (Malka, L. 2014) Golden Lane was more like a planning project. It was about planning the whole city, making the architecture through the idea of city planning. Since for this term’s project for Architecture Design Studio is on architecture and urban design, and my project proposes a house-based mix-used program, I thought that I can build up some correlations between the concepts this essay included and my term project. In 1960s, housing was important. While Peter and Alison Smithson were considering ‘how we can house?’, according to them, as architects there should be found a way to create a homogeneity in the way doing housing. The social housing units should not be like scattered in city. Therefore, the approach of ‘as found’ was standing up for a structure within city that creates hierarchy among people. Moreover, while creating hierarchy among people we should not separate people from each other, but we must find a way to make them live together. Considering the Dikmen Valley where the given site for term project is located, there is scattered condition of houses in the surrounding district of the city. There is the segregation of people over distinctions such as slums-residences, rich-poor. 1960s discussion about segregation and the culture of ‘as found’ asserts slums should not be divided from the more developed part of the city, there should not be separation, in fact everything should flow. Moreover, “Smithsons’ entry criticizes London’s socioeconomic division into separated neighbourhoods.” (Malka, L. 2014). They argue culture should be a whole rather than to create such different status within the city. The certain groups of social people should be all together, there should not be segregation. Additionally, “Smithsons drew their new design without removing the ‘identity’ traces of the bombed area, with a transparent façade that allows the viewer to see the existing city, with correlation to their ‘as found’ concept.” (Malka, L. 2014).  As a reminder, ‘As found’ was related with critical regionalism, vernacular architecture, local qualities and values.  At this point, when I return to my own project, my proposal is continuation of low-level urban texture, which is set against standardized higher-level blocks which has lack of identity. Neither the streets go up nor they become new buildings. Instead, specifically to my proposal, buildings have their form dissolving through the ground so that the streets being more interacted with the buildings; ‘street level buildings’. This is again related with the neighbourhood concept which relies on the local values.

Furthermore, “Smithsons believe that combining old and new will create the new form of collectiveness and public realm. In their photomontages they picked up the modernist’s idea of freestanding building, turned it over by turning solitary building into clusters, and finally put it together with the post war urban fabric.” (Malka, L. 2014).  My representation for this paper is created by using 3D modelling program where I had chance to show the surrounding relations, the old texture ‘as found’ and the new, referring to Golden Lane Project. The black and white conceptualized collage of Golden Lane Project gave me an idea on how to emphasize the network within the old. Because, “in their photomontage Smithsons draw their modernist design on the existing urban fabric.” (Malka, L. 2014). Similarly, I examined the already existed regular fabric of surrounding, buildings, pedestrians, passages, roads. I prolongated this pattern towards valley from the residential area by passing over the given site. The main purpose behind was intertwining the circulation with the urban context while valuing the valley. At the end, that network created within the site shaped from existed street and topography lines in urban scale and worked with the slope. So, while keeping the old in total black, what I wanted to emphasize mostly was to network which is in white coloured lines. In my design, conceptually, networks of pedestrians, passages, roads extended to create such a neighbour pattern by sticking to the identity traces of surrounding.

In their entry at the congress of CIAM, “Smithsons define their own: ‘Street in the Air’, wider, open to its surroundings and successive.” (Malka, L. 2014). They came up with continuous wall like structures where human movements define the space. The house buildings will look like a street, namely; ‘the street the building’. Streets being more interacted with buildings by going up, they are being places and not corridors or balconies. “They offer contiguous network or as they define: a cluster of streets which creates a new urban structure that connects to the existing.” (Malka, L. 2014). What I wanted to express is the network I created within the site, it is not like a new urban structure that connects to the existing but more like a contextually connected suggestion which wants the neighbour pattern to be continued throughout the site as well. So, using the method of Smithsons’ collage, I tried to conceptualize this street level standing where it is but buildings dissolve and come to the human scale. Therefore, this concept improves street level community access to buildings. These descending edges took shape according to the entrances, wind corridors, orientation, dimensions, proportions of enclosed and open spaces.

In short, I have established a connection between the project and concepts mentioned above and my own project, and within the frame of this connection I have tried to develop a conceptual approach and tried to explain it.

Bibliography

Lecture Notes

Smithson, Alison and Peter. “The ‘As Found’ and the ‘Found’” in The Independent Group: Postwar Britain and the Aesthetics of Plenty, Eds. David Robbins,Cambridge. Massachusetts: The MIT·Press, 1990. pp:201-203

Malka, Liran. ALISON and PETER SMITHSON – The Shifts of Ideas from the Golden Lane Proposal to the Robin Hood Gardens (1952-1972). April, 2014.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free